Movies

‘The Irishman’ NYFF review — Scorsese’s tribute to Scorsese

Based on a true story, a hitman for the mob looks back at his life and the events that shaped him in The Irishman.

One-sentence review: The Irishman combines the meditative pace of Silence, the sharp humor and style of The Wolf of Wall Street, and the narrative of Martin Scorsese's greatest gangster movies to form a self-reflective magnum opus.

Details: ? Martin Scorsese // ?? U.S. // ⏳ 209 minutes

The cast: Robert DeNiro, , Al Pacino

Where to watch The Irishman: In theaters November 2nd. On November 27.

The Irishman feels like a culmination of all the films that came before it in Martin Scorsese's filmography. You can piece it together from his various projects. It's deliberately paced and meditative like Silence with a sharp sense of humor like The Wolf of Wall Street. The plot treads close to any of his classic gangster movies and it grapples with toxic masculinity like many of his movies, but Taxi Driver feels like the closest comparison. It feels like an epilogue to his storied career — but it also makes clear that Marty is far from being obsolete. 

Getting the mob back together

If the 2010s have shown us anything, it's that Scorsese isn't done experimenting and trying new things. As much as this feels like a Scorsese picture, it's more like it's influenced by his past work rather than trying to recreate it — even though it reunites him with old collaborators Robert DeNiro and .

The movie, stitched together by long-time editor Thelma Schoonmaker, follows Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran (DeNiro) as he recounts his life as a hitman for Russell Bufalino (Pesci) and his entire organization. The decades-spanning narrative, which required them to digitally de-age the actors, covers Sheeran's beginning as a small-time criminal stealing meat off of butcher trucks to his fateful meeting Russell to his friendship with famed and bombastic labor union leader Jimmy Hoffa (Al Pacino).

THE IRISHMAN (2019) Ray Ramano (Bill Bufalino ) Al Pacino (Jimmy Hoffa) and (Frank Sheeran)

Brilliantly, the movie jumps around in time and feels like it rambles at times — just like you'd expect an old man to talk about the events in his life. The formlessness of the narrative is both an asset and a liability. An asset because it really feels like you're talking to someone about their life. A liability because you do feel the 3 ½ hour runtime at points. 

Balancing crime with comedy and character

However, it is also often hilarious with killer (pun intended) timing that you're able to get through the rough patches with ease. The movie especially shines when Sheeran becomes a confidant for Hoffa, who Pacino plays with all the bombast and energy you'd expect him to deliver in a Scorsese movie — shockingly, this is his first time working with the director. There's plenty of wise guy talk, politicking between various groups, and mob-antics that go wrong and some that go right — everything you'd expect Scorsese to cover. It's the way he covers it that makes The Irishman special. 

Robert DeNiro hasn't been this good in years in his role as Frank. And while many people were tepid on the decision to use the same actors to play characters over a span of decades, it pays off. It makes each character, especially Frank, feel lived in. You feel the toll of every sin he commits weight on him and on his daughter Peggy (a criminally underused Anna Paquin) as time goes by.

It's difficult to describe the plot because the movie is essentially structure-less, but the main throughline of the film is Frank's relationships with Russell and Jimmy and his lack of a relationship with his family. In so many mob movies, including Scorsese's, the men operate unchecked and without moral consequence. The Irishman attempts to reckon with the emotional impact of being in the mob. It's a welcome change of pace late in the movie.

The Irishman ends up being greater than the sum of its parts. It could have been easily cut down and end with the same effect, but each part in a vacuum works so well that it's easy to overlook. Oddly, I think this movie will play well on versus a theater. It's a movie that will immerse you either way.

Karl Delossantos

Hey, I'm Karl, founder and film critic at Smash Cut. I started Smash Cut in 2014 to share my love of movies and give a perspective I haven't yet seen represented. I'm also an editor at The New York Times, a Rotten Tomatoes-approved critic, and a member of the Online Film Critics Society.

Leave a Comment
Published by
Karl Delossantos

Recent Posts

‘Wicked’ defies expectations, a fearless movie-musical | movie review

Wicked, the long-awaited adaptation of the smash Broadway musical, finally flies its way into theaters… Read More

2 days ago

<em>No Other Land</em> is the most important documentary of our time | movie review

No Other Land follows a Palestinian activist as he documents the destruction of his community… Read More

2 months ago

Surreal dramedy <em>The Life of Chuck</em> ponders life and death | TIFF 2024

TIFF 2024 | The Life of Chuck follows an enigmatic man starting as a surrealist… Read More

2 months ago

Diabolically fun horror <em>Heretic</em> will make you believe | TIFF 2024

A pair of young Mormon missionaries find themselves at the center of a sinister plot… Read More

2 months ago

Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield charm and fall in love in <em>We Live In Time</em> | TIFF 2024

Moving back and forth in their history, We Live In Time follows a couple through… Read More

2 months ago

<em>Strange Darling</em>, a thriller to die for | movie review

While it begins as a cat-and-mouse thriller, Strange Darling evolves (and genre-bends) into a psychological… Read More

3 months ago